Skip to Content

Smoothie Vs Shake: What’s the Difference?

smoothie vs shakeThere are many recipes around to help you increase the amount of healthy food you eat. Smoothies and protein shakes are 2 of the most common. Both are deliciously refreshing drinks that are easy to make at home and found in most cafes and restaurants.

People often confuse shakes with smoothies because they contain fruits and vegetables as the main components and have a similar appearance.

So, when it comes to smoothie vs shake, what’s the difference? Well, you’re in luck, since this article has been written just to answer that question to the best of its ability. So, let’s have a look at how these healthy drinks differ from one another.

Read More: Best Blender For Protein Shakes: 7 Top Rated Models

Difference Between Smoothie and Shake

Smoothies and shakes differ in a variety of ways, including texture, flavor, and contents. However, the significant difference is in the macronutrients: smoothies contain carbohydrates, whereas shakes have protein. So, without any further delay, let’s get down to the differences between smoothies and shakes.

Taste and Texture

Let’s start with a look at the texture and flavor of both smoothies and shakes.

You may be asking why texture or consistency is important, and the truth is that many individuals have trouble drinking thick or sludgy liquids.

Keeping this in mind, let’s focus on smoothies first:


Smoothies are thick beverages with a lot of fruit pulp swirling about in them.

The thickness might put some people off, so keep that in mind if you’re thinking about starting to drink them. You can minimize the consistency by mixing the components on a high setting in a powerful blender, but there’s only so much the blender can manage.

Since you’re mixing down raw fruit with all of the pulp still present, smoothies are thick. You’d have fruit juice if you only wanted the juice from the fruit and nothing else.

A second device, the juicer, is required to create fruit juice. However, if you have a blender, you’re limited to preparing smoothies.

There’s now a reason why there are so many drink bars serving smoothies these days in terms of flavor. Fruity drinks are popular among health-conscious consumers, and many people prefer including veggies in their smoothies for a unique twist.


Shakes have a much smoother feel than smoothies. This is because they are heavier than juice yet lack the consistency of smoothies. If you want to add fruit to your shake, you can do so, but it won’t comprise most of the drink.

The inclusion of milk, ice cream, or yogurt gives shakes their thickness. However, there’s no doubting that shakes are lovely.

As you add protein powder to them to make them more deserving of being served as a post-workout snack, the flavor might be affected either favorably or badly.

Read More: How To Make A Protein Shake – 3 Healthy & Delicious Recipes

Health Benefits

Smoothies and shakes are beneficial for health and fitness, but it all depends on your specific health and fitness objectives.

There are a few aspects to think about when deciding between a smoothie and a shake. For instance, if you want to get the most out of them, you’ll want to make sure you consume them at the right time.

For instance, the starch smoothie may provide an energy boost before a workout, but the protein-rich shake is excellent for post-exercise muscle rehabilitation.


The vitamins and minerals obtained from the fruits and vegetables included in a smoothie are the most convincing reason to consume one.

Many would want to boost their fruit and vegetable consumption, but we don’t want to eat plates upon plates of cherries and cabbage to do it. This is why smoothies are so trendy: they’re a quick and easy way to include extra fruits and veggies into your diet. For example, toss a handful of blueberries into your smoothies to reap the antioxidant perks.

Do you want a boost of potassium? Mix in a banana, chopped up. You might be asking if smoothies contain ice cream at this point, and the response is no. In most smoothies, you won’t find any dairy.

Smoothies also include carbs, which are an essential macronutrient for exercising. Because fruits and vegetables are abundant in carbohydrates, a typical smoothie may serve as an excellent pre-workout extra kick.


If you’re looking for a shake description, it’s just a milkshake with fruit in it — simple enough.

Shakes are not quite as nutritious as smoothies because they contain a lot of high-fat dairies, such as ice cream or yogurt. If you use skim milk, then they aren’t quite as calorific.

Also, it relies on what you put in the smoothie because adding nut butter and protein powder boosts the protein and fat amount.

Shakes are not suggested for weight reduction in general unless it’s a fat-loss brand shake. They’re generally the most effective for gaining muscle.

It’s because they’re high in protein, which is the main component of muscle. For this purpose, many bodybuilders and weightlifters choose to drink a post-workout smoothie.

Read More: How to Make Protein Shakes Taste Better: 10 Simple Tips

Which is Healthier – Smoothie or Shake?

is a smoothie healthier than a shakeYou may be wondering if a shake or a smoothie is healthier for you. The answer is very dependent on the ingredients in the recipe and what you hope to achieve by taking it. As a pre-workout drink, a smoothie with predominantly fruit and some veggie elements would be preferable.

This type of meal has a lot of carbs, which your system will use as fuel throughout a workout. Carbs, unlike fat and protein, break down quickly and easily. Therefore, as a post-workout drink, protein-rich shakes are preferable. Because muscle repair is primarily reliant on protein, it’s critical to pick your post-workout food carefully.

Shakes also include carbohydrates, making them the ideal combo for getting the most out of your workout session. If you’re trying to substitute a meal, a shake or a smoothie mix with enough fat and protein is generally the best option.

People frequently drink a smoothie with berries, broccoli, and almond butter and then ask why they would be starving half an hour later.

Consider smoothies in the very same way that you wouldn’t anticipate a bowl of strawberries to keep you full for the whole afternoon.

By putting whey protein, almond butter, or hemp seeds into your smoothie, you may make it as nutritious as a shake.

Can You Drink Smoothies and Shakes Every Day?

The same as anything else, smoothies and shakes should be taken in moderation. They’re sugar and calorie-rich, so you may gain weight if you have too much.

If you make a shake or a smoothie yourself at home (rather than buying it from a store), then there are no preservatives or additives that will make your drink more sugary. However, adding fruit like bananas can increase the caloric content of your smoothie.

If you need to eat more veggies rather than stocking up on fruits to get rid of weight, using vegetables is an excellent way to do this because they are nutrient-packed but aren’t very sugary. It’s also effortless to add vegetables, like spinach or kale, to your smoothie.

Some vegetables have high sugar content, so use these with care if you’re on a diet.

Read More: Best Blender for Smoothies with Frozen Fruit: 3 Top Models

Smoothie Vs Shake: Final Thoughts

Based on your dietary requirements, smoothies and shakes are both healthy drinks you can make at home. Pre-workout smoothies are the best option for activity nutrition, while shakes are perfect for post-workout nourishment.

When purchasing these drinks at a cafe, ensure you know which one you are buying. This will help you understand if you’re getting a more nutritious drink or not.

Remember that there’s no “healthier” smoothie or shake, as the ingredients vary from recipe to recipe. However, if you have a lot of fruit and vegetables in your smoothie, it will be healthier for you than a milkshake with lots of dairy and fat.

Neither option is healthy or unhealthy, so pick your drink carefully! Overall, both shakes and smoothies are beneficial for everybody who wants to improve their nutrition by including extra fruits and vegetables into their diet.